Mama Mia Pizzeria

Reviews

• Gracie P.

  star star star star star_border 26 June 2026

  I tried to order online but the system wasn't working so I ended up having to call. The wait was about 20-25 minutes? Not too bad for a Saturday night, late night if I can add. It must have been close to 10.
  
  I love oven baked sandwiches and have a soft spot for a turkey baked sandwich.
  
  Let me say the serving was HUGE. I couldn't even eat half and the best part of all was the turkey was REAL turkey--no deli slices here!!!
  
  The bruschetta was very so so, it smelled great but wasn't quite all there.
  
  I did love being able to have a cocktail at Lucy's while I waited for them to finish the order though! Will definitely try again soon.

• Ashley L.

  star star star star_border star_border 25 June 2026

  Really like the one on Bullard near my place so wanted to try the one in Tower District. Called in the order and the guy that took my order was very nice!
  
  Ordered the baked turkey sandwich and added the deluxe it to make it even better. Also asked if I could add extra jalapeños. The spicier the better! He had no problem with that and said my order would be ready in 20 minutes.
  
  Picked up the order. The guys were nice. Definitely not as cheery and talkative as the other one. Not as welcoming anyways.
  
  Thankfully the baked turkey sandwich was just as good as the other one. Adding jalapeños made the sandwich even better! The ingredients in the sandwich like the tomatoes, lettuce and jalapeños were fresh and delicious. I ordered it without mayo. There definitely wasn't a lot of turkey meat in it. The other one has much more which makes the cost more worth it. It is a little pricey. The good thing is the sandwiches are huge. You get two lunches. The bread is definitely a big plus that makes the sandwich so good!
  
  The place is very clean and there's like an open bar right next to it. They are connected.
  
  The one on Bullard is much better! Sticking with that one.

• Nicola B.

  star star star star star_border 12 June 2026

  I've wanted to try Mama Mia for awhile now. This past Friday I was at Lucy's Lounge for a drink with a friend around dinner time, so we decided to order a pizza.
  
  The pizzeria is located inside the same building so you can order and they'll bring food out to your table in the bar. The counter is stocked with fresh water, tons of plates and napkins etc - but they'll bring everything you need out with your plate.
  
  Service was friendly. The prices are pretty high here - it's $20 after tax for a small. It's a decent size for two people, around 10". We ordered the Mediterranean, which comes with mozzarella, feta, garlic, artichokes, onions, and sundried tomatoes.
  
  It came out super fresh and steaming hot. They place it on a corrugated card plate, which was very welcome because a lot of grease had run out of the pizza. Surprisingly, though, the crust was still super crisp and the pizza wasn't greasy at all. The sauce is rich, very herby, and the cheese was generous. It's a fantastic pizza - nice and crispy on the bottom with a fluffy crust on the outside, and there weren't any dry spots. It was very garlicky, which I like, but if you don't like a lot of garlic you should probably avoid that as a topping.
  
  All in it was a great experience, and though a bit pricey the small was perfect for sharing and at $11 each we were pretty satisfied.

• Nathaniel M.

  star star star star_border star_border 11 June 2026

  Heard about this spot thru a friend,so decided to try it.I ordered the original calzone. It comes with just beef and cheese,nd it was amazing. The food here is great. But this place is kind of pricey for what it is and they do not deliver at this location which sucks. You can get uber eats here though.

• John L.

  star star star star star_border 10 June 2026

  Really good pizza! It is a shared building with a bar and the only times I've been there they had live music playing which is cool, but just understand if you go there for a restaurant vibe this isn't the place. But the food is great!